Satisfying Audiences Blog

Satisfying Audiences

What’s next for media paywalls?

15 May 2014 · By Sandy MacLeod

Although the legacy meter model has generated some modest revenues for media companies in the short term, the industry will need to develop new, longer-term revenue streams to keep the momentum going as the meter model inevitably sputters out.

Recently, I participated in an industry panel to discuss the paywall experience to date, looking at such areas as the various techniques used, successes, failures, and what might be the next chapter for paid content in the news media business.

It was only a couple of years ago that there was debate about whether our industry should erect paywalls as part of our digital strategies. In 2013, that question was answered, as most publishers actually jumped on board with an initiative for paid digital content. In fact, some 500 newspapers in North America have a paywall in place, most having opted for some type of meter approach.

So has the jump to a paywall made a significant difference for newspaper companies?

It sure has for The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, and a few others.

But for the majority of North American newspaper publishers, the move to a paid digital content strategy has worked on some fronts and not so well on others.

Clearly, bundling print and digital offerings together has opened a new revenue stream for many publishers. In some cases it has resulted in a nice, one-time lift in revenues. For others, it has allowed for more innovation in pricing, policy changes around vacation credits, and new subscription sales.

These efforts have added millions of dollars to the coffers of media companies, with most having brilliantly executed numerous changes to their pricing and their go-to-market strategies.

However, the majority of the new cash generated has some link back to the print legacy business. That means the move has been a great short-term success for many, but unless the new cash is wisely used to develop new, longer-term revenue streams, the revenue bump will quickly fade.

The number of digital-only subscribers generated by newspaper publishers in North America is small. In most cases, the volumes are 5% to 10% of their print circulation and a fraction of 1% of their total unique visitors. At the same time, the price charged is usually 20% to 25% of a traditional print subscription.

It’s a nice start, but it’s not enough to make up for the lost advertising revenues in the print business — and it’s clearly not the end of the digital story.

I wish I could point to poor execution of paid digital content activities, but on the whole it has been really well-managed.

I believe that over the next 24 months we will see the legacy meter model (yes, legacy only after two years) fade into the background.

In its place we can expect to see new alternatives emerge, such as premium sites, tablet experiments, new smartphone developments, and creative concepts that we’ve not yet even imagined. As well, we might likely see in the next year or two innovations around the idea of selling content memberships rather than newspaper subscriptions.

It’s unfortunate the meter paywall approach is turning out not to be the saviour it was hoped it would be. But as has been said many times before, hope is not a good strategy.

I am optimistic that new business models will emerge, which is one reason that I firmly believe it is an extremely interesting time to be in the news media business.

print article send to friend

blog comments powered by Disqus
About this blog

The Satisfying Audiences Blog aims to reflect print and digital content not just across platforms but extending into consumer events, non-news-related subscriptions and other audience vehicles for newsmedia companies. This blog written by INMA members is dedicated to identifying the emerging linkages between content, audiences, and platforms. The blog is an initiative by the INMA North America Division Board of Directors.

Meet the bloggers

Julie Anderson
Senior Vice President of Digital Publishing/Florida
Tribune Publishing
Orlando, Floria, USA
send message

Nadine Chevolleau
Consumer Marketing
The Toronto Star
Toronto, Ontario, Canada
send message

Kathleen Coleman
Sales & Marketing
S-R Media
Spokane, Washington, USA
send message

Kevin Curnock
General Manager
Brunswick News
St. John, New Brunswick, Canada
send message

Jim Fleigner
Managing Partner
Impact Consultancy
Santa Monica, California, United States
send message

Sara Hill
Toronto, Ontario, Canada
send message

Dan Johnson
Vice President,
Business Development
Gilbert, Arizona, USA
send message

Sandy MacLeod
Chief Operating Officer, Print
The Toronto Star/Metro English
Toronto, Ontario, Canada
send message

John Newby
Muskogee Phoenix
Muskogee, Oklahoma, USA
send message

Nicki Purcell
Chief Digital Officer and Senior Vice President of Consumer Sales
The Dallas Morning News
Dallas, Texas, USA
send message

Maria Terrell
Director of Content
Dallas, Texas, USA
send message

New York City, New York, USA


RSS feed

Blog archives

May 2016 ( 2 )
April 2016 ( 2 )
March 2016 ( 2 )
February 2016 ( 3 )
January 2016 ( 3 )
December 2015 ( 2 )
November 2015 ( 4 )
October 2015 ( 3 )
September 2015 ( 4 )
August 2015 ( 2 )
July 2015 ( 4 )
June 2015 ( 4 )
May 2015 ( 4 )
April 2015 ( 4 )
March 2015 ( 2 )
February 2015 ( 5 )
January 2015 ( 4 )
December 2014 ( 3 )
November 2014 ( 3 )
October 2014 ( 2 )

Blog roll

Brain Traffic

Join INMA Today
Upcoming Events
INMA Ideas Day on Audience Development
Amsterdam, The Netherlands
17 June 2016
INMA International News Media Conference
São Paulo, Brazil
23-24 August 2016
INMA South Asia News Media Conference
New Delhi, India
30-31 August 2016
INMA European News Media Conference
14-17 September 2016
INMA Latin American News Media Conference
Panama City, Panama
22-23 September 2016
INMA Business Strategies 2020 Conference
Chicago, United States
03-04 October 2016
INMA Silicon Valley Study Tour
San Francisco, United States
17-21 October 2016

More Events

Member Profiles

  • Chris Fehrmann
    United States

  • Mariam Baig

  • Dan Gaydou
    United States

  • Simon Dowrick

  • Constanze Van Overdam

  • Michal Gwiazdowski

©2016 INMA | Home | About | Contact | RSS | Privacy